News

Pakistan does not lack entrepreneurs. It does not lack talent, ambition, consumers, or business opportunities.

What Pakistan desperately lacks is a system that allows businesses to operate without being trapped in layers of bureaucracy.

For many entrepreneurs, the real challenge begins not in the marketplace but in government offices.

Licences. NOCs. Registrations. Inspections. Certifications. Tax notices. Departmental approvals. Files moving from one desk to another.

The businessman wants to build a company. The system keeps asking him to build relationships with departments.

Bureaucracy: The Elephant in the Room

Pakistan cannot seriously discuss improving its business environment without confronting one of its biggest structural problems: excessive bureaucracy and discretionary government power.

When an official has the authority to approve your licence, stop your operation, raise an objection, initiate an inspection, or keep your application pending, that authority must be accompanied by extraordinary transparency and accountability.

Otherwise, discretion can become pressure.

Pressure can become harassment.

And in the worst cases, harassment can create opportunities for corruption and demands for unofficial payments.

This is where entrepreneurs can feel trapped.

If a businessman needs an approval to continue operating and an official can indefinitely delay that approval, the relationship between the citizen and the state becomes dangerously unequal.

Some businesspeople describe such situations as bureaucratic “blackmail”: comply with an unofficial demand, use connections, or risk watching your legitimate business remain stuck in paperwork.

Such allegations should never be generalized to every civil servant. Pakistan has many honest and professional government officials. But a good system should not depend upon whether an entrepreneur happens to encounter a good officer.

A good system should make abuse difficult in the first place.

Corruption Is Not Just a Moral Problem — It Is an Economic Tax

The World Bank’s Pakistan Enterprise Survey 2022 found that 15.4% of surveyed firms identified corruption as their biggest obstacle.

Think about what corruption means for an entrepreneur:

• An unofficial payment is effectively another tax.

• A deliberately delayed approval is a cost.

• An unnecessary inspection is a cost.

• Repeated visits to government departments are a cost.

• A business closed or disrupted while waiting for paperwork represents lost revenue, lost productivity, and potentially lost jobs.

These costs eventually reach ordinary Pakistanis through higher prices, reduced investment, and fewer employment opportunities.

Stop Treating Entrepreneurs Like Suspects

Pakistan desperately needs investment.

It needs factories.

It needs exporters.

It needs taxpayers.

It needs small businesses to become medium-sized businesses and medium-sized companies to become large corporations.

Yet an entrepreneur can sometimes feel that the administrative system treats business activity as something that must constantly prove its innocence.

Businesses should certainly obey laws concerning taxation, consumer protection, food safety, labour standards, and environmental protection.

But regulation and bureaucratic harassment are not the same thing.

• Regulation establishes clear rules.

• Bureaucratic harassment uses uncertainty and discretionary power.

A modern state should know the difference.

“Invest in Pakistan” Must Mean Something

Pakistan regularly invites domestic and foreign investors to put their money into the country.

But investment conferences and slogans mean little if an entrepreneur subsequently has to spend months navigating departments for permissions.

You cannot tell investors:

“Come to Pakistan.”

And then confront them with:

• Get another NOC.

• Visit another department.

• Your file is still pending.

• Come again next week.

• There is another objection.

• Speak to the concerned officer.

That is not an investment strategy.

That is administrative friction.

The Most Dangerous Power Is Unaccountable Discretion

The central issue is not simply the number of government employees.

It is discretion without sufficient transparency.

Whenever one individual can decide whether a business moves forward or remains stuck, the possibility of misuse increases.

Pakistan therefore needs to remove unnecessary human discretion from routine business regulation.

If a licence requires five documents and a fixed government fee, an online system should verify those documents, collect the fee, and issue the licence within a legally defined period.

The businessman should not need:

• A source

• A recommendation

• Personal connections

• Unofficial payments

Digitise It — or Abolish It

Every business-related government requirement should face a simple test:

Is this approval genuinely necessary to protect the public?

If yes, digitise it.

If no, abolish it.

Essential Reforms

• Every NOC should have a justification.

• Every inspection should have a digital record.

• Every government fee should be publicly displayed and electronically payable.

• Every objection should be issued in writing.

• Every application should have a tracking number.

• Every department should have a statutory deadline.

• Every official exercising regulatory authority over businesses should be accountable for unexplained delays.

If a department cannot explain why an entrepreneur needs a particular piece of paper, perhaps the entrepreneur should not need that paper at all.

Make the Officer Accountable Too

Pakistan’s regulatory culture often focuses heavily on what businesses must do.

There must also be a serious discussion about what government officials must do.

If a businessman violates the law, hold him accountable.

But if an official deliberately delays a legitimate application, demands an unofficial payment, misuses an inspection, creates an unjustified objection, or harasses a business, there must also be consequences.

Accountability cannot travel in only one direction.

A strong state does not mean powerful officials and powerless citizens.

A strong state means powerful institutions, clear laws, and accountable officials.

Pakistan’s Entrepreneurs Need Freedom to Work

The tragedy is that Pakistan possesses tremendous entrepreneurial energy.

Pakistanis build businesses under difficult economic conditions. They survive inflation, currency fluctuations, expensive energy, financing constraints, and intense competition.

Government bureaucracy should not become another opponent they have to defeat.

The job of the state is not to guarantee businessmen profits.

Its job is to guarantee them:

• Fair rules

• Equal treatment

• Predictable administration

Let businesses compete against businesses.

Let products compete against products.

Let entrepreneurs compete through innovation, quality, and price.

But do not force entrepreneurs to compete over who has the strongest connections inside government departments.

The Message Is Simple

If Pakistan genuinely wants economic growth, it must stop measuring business reform by announcements and start measuring it by the entrepreneur’s actual experience.

Ask the real questions:

• How many offices must he visit?

• How many approvals must he obtain?

• How long can an official hold his application?

• Can he complete the entire process without knowing anyone inside the department?

• Can he refuse an unofficial payment without fearing retaliation or unnecessary delay?

These are the real tests of a business-friendly country.

Pakistan does not need another slogan about ease of doing business.

It needs a fundamental change in the relationship between bureaucracy and business.

What Needs to Change?

• Reduce bureaucratic power.

• Eliminate unnecessary NOCs.

• Digitise approvals.

• Minimise human discretion.

• Investigate corruption complaints.

• Punish harassment.

• Protect honest officials.

• Protect honest businesses.

Final Thought

“An entrepreneur should never need the favour of an official to exercise a right already granted to him by law.”

Until that principle becomes part of Pakistan’s administrative culture, bureaucracy will continue to consume the time, money, and energy that entrepreneurs should be investing in businesses, jobs, and economic growth.